Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Series

Filter families — the series

2 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Three filter families at order 5, all with the same half-power point. At three times the corner the Chebyshev is -64.0 dB down, the Butterworth -47.7 dB and the Bessel -28.3 dB. The inset is the passband at forty times the vertical magnification, which is the only place the Chebyshev's half-decibel of ripple is visible at all.

    Three families, one corner

    Butterworth is flat, Chebyshev is steep, Bessel has good delay. None of those is a number, so the table they appear in cannot answer the question anybody has. Here each family's poles are computed from its definition, built as an actual network, and then measured — starting with the step every comparison skips.

    part 1 · filters
  2. Four families at order 5, and the 2 zeros in the stopband. computed by solving, not by drawing. The elliptic design is drawn at a selectivity of 0.8, so its stopband is asked to begin at 1.250 times the corner, and the degree equation returns 38.68 dB for it at 0.5 dB of ripple. From the stopband edge outward the elliptic response never rises above -38.7 dB; the steepest all-pole family of the same order is only -19.0 dB down there and does not reach -38.7 dB until 1.77 times the corner. That is what 2 transmission zeros buy. The price is in the same picture: the elliptic stopband has a floor and an all-pole one does not, so beyond 2.0×fc the all-pole response is the lower of the two and keeps going.

    The zeros that buy an order

    Butterworth, Chebyshev and Bessel all fall because their denominator grows, so the only way to make one fall faster is another pole. An elliptic filter puts zeros in the stopband instead, and reaches forty decibels at twice the corner with two poles where the steepest all-pole family needs five. What it charges is a stopband that stops falling — measured here at −38.7 dB, and overtaken by an ordinary Chebyshev two corners out.

    part 2 · filters

All series