Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Series

Impedance scaling — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. One Sallen-Key design at 10 kΩ, and the band of impedance levels it survives. computed by solving, not by drawing. A 10.0 kHz unity-gain Sallen-Key section realised at seven impedance levels three decades apart, with every resistance multiplied and every capacitance divided by the same factor. The design is exactly invariant: the solved magnitudes agree to 1.0e-15 of each other across all seven and every frequency in the passband, which is the last bits of a double rather than a good approximation. The realisation is not, because two of its quantities do not scale — 50 Ω of amplifier output resistance and 2 pF of stray capacitance to everywhere — and they bind at opposite ends. Inside 0.1 dB the band runs 31.6 Ω to 31.6 kΩ, with the least departure of 0.0133 dB at 1000 Ω; at this setting it is 0.036 dB at 20.0 kHz. The consideration that does not appear on either axis is noise: the resistors' density goes as √R, so across the six decades drawn the noise moves by 1000 times and points at the low end of the band.

    The same filter a thousand times larger

    Multiply every resistance by a thousand and divide every capacitance by a thousand and the response does not change — not approximately, but to a part in ten to the fifteenth, which is the last bits of a double. So a designer has a free parameter that the design says nothing about, and what decides it is the two quantities that refuse to scale: fifty ohms of amplifier output resistance at one end and two picofarads of stray at the other. Between them the realisation survives over three decades of impedance level and nowhere else.

    part 1 · filters
  2. An order-6 cascade at 10 kΩ: a band 10× wide. computed by solving, not by drawing. A 10.0 kHz unity-gain Butterworth of order 6, 3 Sallen-Key sections in cascade, realised at seven impedance levels three decades apart, with every resistance multiplied and every capacitance divided by the same factor. The design is exactly invariant: the solved magnitudes agree to 4.0e-15 of each other across all seven and every frequency in the passband, which is the last bits of a double rather than a good approximation. The realisation is not, because two of its quantities do not scale — 50 Ω of amplifier output resistance and 2 pF of stray capacitance to everywhere — and they bind at opposite ends. Inside 0.1 dB the band runs 316 Ω to 3.16 kΩ, with the least departure of 0.0763 dB at 1000 Ω; at this setting it is 0.182 dB at 12.9 kHz. The consideration that does not appear on either axis is noise: the resistors' density goes as √R, so across the six decades drawn the noise moves by 1000 times and points at the low end of the band.

    The band that closes with the order

    One Sallen-Key section is inside a tenth of a decibel of its own design over three decades of impedance level, bounded below by fifty ohms of amplifier output resistance and above by two picofarads of stray. Give it three more sections and the band is one decade; give it four and there is no impedance level at all that meets a tenth of a decibel. Every section brings three more nodes each carrying their own stray and one more amplifier carrying its own output resistance, so the floor rises with the order until it crosses the tolerance — a boundary in the order rather than in the impedance.

    part 2 · filters
  3. At the order a cascade runs out, a ladder still has 4.2 decades of level. computed by solving, not by drawing. How many decades of impedance level each structure can be built at while staying inside 0.1 dB of its own design, against order. Both carry two picofarads of stray at every node. The cascade also carries fifty ohms of amplifier output resistance, a fixed resistance, which binds it from below; its floor rises 8.5× over the four orders drawn, to 0.114 dB at order eight. The ladder's inductors carry a fixed resistance per henry instead — a fixed quality factor, which scales with the design and bounds nothing — so what limits it from below is a few milliohms of track, and at order nine it still has 4.20 decades with a floor of 0.0337 dB, 3.3× its own floor at order three against the cascade's 8.5×.

    The band that does not close

    A cascade of active sections can be built at three decades of impedance level at second order, one at sixth, and none at all at eighth — the band shuts by half a decade per order because two fixed quantities bind it from opposite ends. A doubly terminated ladder has only one of those quantities, because an inductor's loss is a fixed quality factor rather than a fixed resistance and therefore scales with the design. At order nine it still has four decades.

    part 3 · filters
  4. The floor rises as the 1.06 power of the order, and the arithmetic gives out first. computed by solving, not by drawing. The least departure a doubly terminated ladder can achieve at any impedance level, against order — the floor, which is what is left when the tolerance the band is drawn at is taken away. It rises from 0.0087 dB at order three to 0.0389 dB at order 13, as the 1.06 power of the order, so the order at which it reaches the 0.1 dB the band is drawn at is near 32. Drawn over it are the same networks with one imperfection removed at a time, and they do not add: the winding loss alone leaves a larger departure than the complete realisation does, because the track resistance is in series with the load and lifts the passband exactly where the winding loss droops it. The stray capacitance contributes nothing at all, since the level that minimises the departure is a few ohms. What ends the sweep is neither: the continued-fraction synthesis loses its leading coefficients to cancellation and stalls at order 9 for a Butterworth and 14 for a Chebyshev.

    The floor that outlives the arithmetic

    A band of impedance levels is what a tolerance allows; a floor is what a structure has. Measured at six orders, a doubly terminated ladder's floor rises as the 1.06 power of the order and would not reach a tenth of a decibel until order thirty-two — an order nobody builds. What stops the sweep is neither the structure nor the parasitics: the continued fraction that turns a reflection polynomial into element values loses its leading coefficients to cancellation and stalls at order nine for a Butterworth and fourteen for a Chebyshev.

    part 4 · filters

All series