Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Series

Mutual inductance — the series

3 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The coupling coefficient, from two measurements that do not know it. computed by solving, not by drawing. Two windings in series, connected one way and then the other, each solved as a netlist and its inductance read out of the impedance. The two differ by four times the mutual inductance, so k comes out of the difference and the geometry never enters. The recovered value matches the one stamped into the coupling to 2.4e-15 at eight couplings from 0.1 to 0.99 — which is the second route the new element needed, since neither current law nor the energy balance can see a mutual inductance at all. Their sum stays at L₁ + L₂ throughout, which is the check that the two measurements are of one pair.

    One number from two measurements

    Neither of the two standing checks on a solved circuit can see a mutual inductance. A coupling adds no current anywhere, so Kirchhoff's law is unmoved by it; a coupled pair dissipates nothing, so the energy balance is unmoved too. A coupling stamped into the wrong row would produce a well-formed solution to a different circuit and both checks would pass — so the field needed a third route, and the one it uses is the bench method: connect the windings in series one way, then the other, and the difference is four times the mutual inductance.

    part 1 · magnetics
  2. A 10 mH winding read at 1 kHz while a 40 mH winding coupled to it at k = 0.99 is loaded from a short to an open. computed by solving, not by drawing at 61 loads for each coupling. Open, the first winding reads 10.0000 mH, its own inductance. Shorted, it reads 199.00 µH — L₁(1 − k²), the leakage seen from this side, because the second winding's current cancels all of the flux the two share. The change happens around a load equal to the second winding's reactance, 251 Ω. At k = 0.5, 0.9, 0.99 and 0.999 the shorted readings are 7500 µH, 1900 µH, 199.00 µH, 19.99 µH.

    The leakage a series reading cannot see

    The series-aiding and series-opposing readings recover a coupling coefficient to fifteen figures on a netlist, and on a bench with a 0.1% meter they recover it to about 0.001 at every coupling — which is useless exactly where transformers live. At k = 0.999 the leakage, L₁(1 − k²), is two thousandths of the winding, and the series route leaves it 133% uncertain: 88 of 400 seeded benches report a negative leakage. Shorting the other winding reads the leakage directly, to the meter's own 0.1%, and recovers k 943 times more precisely at 0.999. The short is a short only where the shorted winding's reactance dwarfs its resistance by 10k/√(1 − k²), and the winding to short is the one with the longer time constant.

    part 2 · magnetics
  3. A shorted reading at k = 0.99: within 1% of the leakage from 279 Hz to 112 kHz, too high below through the winding's resistance and above through the leakage's resonance with 100 pF, at 1.13 MHz. computed by solving, not by drawing, in closed form, and by a netlist with a coupling element at three frequencies. The reading Im(Z)/ω at the driven terminals of a 10 mH and 40 mH pair, with the other winding shorted through its own 1 Ω, 0.5 Ω in the driven winding and 100 pF across it, against frequency, as a fractional distance from the leakage L₁(1 − k²) = 199.00 µH. Below the band the short does not cancel the shared flux. Above it the leakage and the capacitance resonate, at 1.13 MHz, and the reading rises to meet them. Band: 279 Hz to 112 kHz, a ratio of 402.1.

    The window that moves

    A shorted winding reads its own leakage only above the frequency at which the short really cancels the shared flux, and only below the leakage's resonance with whatever capacitance is across it. A tighter coupling raises the first edge as one over the root of 1 − k², and it was expected to pull the second down and close the window. It raises the second as well, by the same factor. So the band is 82 Hz to 36 kHz at k = 0.9, 279 Hz to 112 kHz at 0.99 and 2.81 kHz to 1.12 MHz at 0.9999, about four hundred times wide throughout. Its width is 0.01·L₂/(R₂k√(L₁C)), with the leakage nowhere in it, so what closes the window is the winding and not the coupling. Reading the real part as well is exact on paper and limited by phase.

    part 3 · magnetics

All series