Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Series

Probe loading — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Two probes on a 2.0 kΩ source. computed by solving, not by drawing twice per frequency: the node alone, and the node with the probe's elements across it. The one-to-one probe's 115.0 pF makes the reading one per cent wrong at 6.79 kHz. The ten-to-one probe puts 12.8 pF in series with the cable, so its tip sees 11.5 pF and the same error arrives at 69.2 kHz — 10 times further up, bought with a factor of ten in signal — the two edges stand in the ratio of the tip capacitances, 10.00. At direct current neither probe is capacitive at all and the ten-to-one still reads 0.02% low, because 10 MΩ across 2.0 kΩ is a divider.

    The probe is part of the circuit

    A one-to-one oscilloscope probe on a two-kilohm source gives a reading that is one per cent wrong at 6.8 kHz. Not because the instrument is inaccurate — it is reading correctly — but because the hundred and fifteen picofarads at the end of the cable are across the node, and above that frequency the trace on the screen is a picture of a circuit that only exists while the probe is attached.

    part 2 · instruments
  2. How much faster an instrument must be for 10% of inflation. computed by solving, not by drawing. The quadrature rule answers 2.182× and gives the same answer for every instrument, because it contains no instrument. Measured on the solved network, a one-pole front end needs 2.79×, two poles need 3.97×, three need 4.87× and four need 5.62× — between 28% and 215% more than the rule asks for. The rule errs optimistic at every pole count, which is the wrong direction.

    The instrument's own rise time

    Rise times add in quadrature, so ten per cent of inflation needs an instrument 2.18 times faster than the edge. That constant contains no instrument. Measured on the solved network it is 2.79 for a one-pole front end, 3.97 for two, 4.87 for three and 5.62 for four — the rule is optimistic at every pole count, which is the wrong direction for a rule of thumb to err in.

    part 3 · instruments
  3. What each factor of attenuation buys on a 2.0 kΩ source. computed by solving, not by drawing at 12 probe ratios: the one-per-cent frequency bisected on the node with and without the probe, against the frequency a tip capacitance alone would predict. A one-to-one probe reaches 6.79 kHz and a hundred-to-one 692 kHz. The first step, from 1× to 2×, multiplies the bandwidth by 2.03 for a factor of two in signal; the two routes differ by at most 1.8% across the sweep, and they differ at all only because the probe's 1.0 MΩ is already 0.20% of the reading before any frequency is applied.

    The probe that takes a tenth

    A ten-to-one probe buys an order of bandwidth for a tenth of the signal, and on a two-kilohm source the bandwidth is exact: 6.79 kHz becomes 69.2 kHz. The tenth of the signal is not a tenth of the signal-to-noise ratio. Solved resistor by resistor, the noise referred to the tip goes from 1.782 µV to 55.78 µV — a factor of 31.3 — because the divider that does the attenuating is nine megohms and a megohm, and √(n(n−1)kT/C) on the cable's own capacitance has no source resistance in it at all.

    part 4 · instruments
  4. A 150 nH ground lead on a ten-to-one probe, at a 50 Ω source: the screen shows 49.4% of overshoot ringing at 121 MHz on an edge that has none. computed by solving, not by drawing, twice. A 1 V step from a 50 Ω source, watched through a ten-to-one probe with 11.5 pF at its tip, its ground returned through 150 nH of lead — about fifteen centimetres — and the scope reading the tip against the lead's end (solid, from residues; dots, a trapezoidal march, peak 1.4942). The same probe with its ground at the circuit's ground (dashed). The node itself steps cleanly. With the lead the tip capacitance and the lead inductance resonate at 1/(2π√(LC)) = 121 MHz, damped only by the source: ζ = (Rs/2)√(C/L) = 0.219, and the display overshoots by 49.4%.

    The ring the ground lead adds

    Every earlier measurement of a probe returned it to the circuit's ground directly. A real ten-to-one probe returns through fifteen centimetres of clip lead, about 150 nH, and its 11.5 pF tip and that lead are a series resonance at 121 MHz across the node being watched. The only damping it has is the source's own resistance, ζ = (Rs/2)·√(C/L), so the screen shows 49.4% of overshoot on a clean step from 50 Ω, 87.1% from 10 Ω, and none above 228 Ω — the stiffer the node, the worse the picture. Solved by residues and by a march of the netlist, the overshoot follows the second-order law at every source. A spring tip's 5 nH rings at 664 MHz and not at all from 50 Ω; a 150 Ω resistor in series with the tip brings a clip lead under 2% at the price of a 3.65 ns rise.

    part 5 · instruments

All series