Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Series

Real resistor — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. A 10 kΩ resistor, and the 19.3 MHz it is one below. computed by solving, not by drawing. The dashed line is R, which is what the symbol means. The solid line is the same part with 8.0 nH of lead inductance in series and 0.40 pF across the body, solved as a three-element network and checked against the closed form for the same three elements to 3.3e-16. It is ten per cent below its own value by 19.3 MHz, and which of the two parasitics does that depends on the resistance: the shunt capacitance wins above 91.02 Ω and the lead inductance below it. The slider is the resistance, and the departure frequency it moves is not monotonic — it rises a decade per decade of resistance, peaks near 91.02 Ω at 2.00 GHz, and falls a decade per decade after that.

    The resistor that is only a resistor

    A capacitor becomes an inductor above a frequency its leads decide, and an inductor becomes a capacitor. The third member of that family is the one nobody draws, and it is the only one whose edge is not monotonic in its own value: a ten-megohm resistor stops being one at 19 kilohertz, a ten-ohm resistor at 92 megahertz, and between them sits a resistance whose impedance is flat to fourth order — 91.02 ohms here, which is the square root of L over C divided by the root of one plus root two.

    part 1 · frequency
  2. Flat in angle at √(L/C), 141.42 Ω, and flat in size at 91.018 Ω. computed by solving, not by drawing, at 127 resistances on the closed form the network was checked against. The upper curve is the frequency at which the part's size is 1% away from R, the lower one the frequency at which its angle reaches 1°. Both are V-shaped and their points are in different places: the angle's first-order term vanishes at √(L/C) = 141.42 Ω, bisected on the measured slope to ten figures, and the size's second-order term at 91.018 Ω. The widest 1° band is 1.13 GHz, at 150.69 Ω; the widest 1% band is 1.66 GHz, at 95.806 Ω. At 91.018 Ω, flattest in size, the angle reaches 1° by 53.9 MHz. The flat line is 139 MHz, where a 6 mm body is one degree long: it binds the angle's edge from 118.72 Ω to 168.88 Ω and the size's from 43.947 Ω to 359.53 Ω.

    The resistor that is right in size and wrong in angle

    A resistor's impedance departs from its value in size as the square of frequency and in angle as the first power, so the angle always leaves first: at ten milliohms and at a megohm alike, where the angle has reached a degree the size is still only 152 parts per million out. One time constant, L/R − RC, sets that degree — 4.00 nanoseconds and 695 kilohertz at ten kilohms, 800 nanoseconds and 3.47 kilohertz for a ten-milliohm shunt. The resistance flattest in angle is exactly √(L/C), 141.42 ohms, the value the size question rejected; at the 91.02 ohms flattest in size the angle reaches a degree by 53.9 megahertz, and no resistance is flat in both.

    part 2 · frequency
  3. With 100% of its capacitance to its mounting, a 141.4 Ω helix is 1.37° out at 100 MHz, not 2.7 × 10⁻³°. computed by solving, not by drawing. The angle of the impedance of a 141.4 Ω resistor — √(L/C) for 8 nH of lead and 0.4 pF — against frequency: the three-element part with all 0.4 pF across its film (dashed), and a helix of 32 turns with the same totals (solid), 0% of the capacitance between adjacent turns and 100% from the turns to the part's mounting, with one end grounded. At √(L/C) the three-element part has no first-order angle and rises as the cube of frequency. The helix is not flat there: its capacitance to the mounting counts only a third, so its own flat resistance is √(3L/C) = 244.9 Ω, and at 141.4 Ω its angle is first order in frequency — 1.37° at 100 MHz against 2.7 × 10⁻³°.

    The resistor that is a helix

    A spiral-cut film resistor is a helix, and its capacitance is distributed along the cut rather than lumped across the ends. Where it goes decides whether the three-element model survives. Capacitance between adjacent turns bridges each turn's own piece of film, and a helix of any number of turns built that way is the three-element part exactly — to 8×10⁻¹³ at 64 turns. Capacitance from the turns to what the part is mounted over is different: its current returns through only part of the film, it weighs (4N² − 1)/(12N²) of its value, a third in the limit, and the resistance with the flattest angle moves from √(L/C) = 141.4 Ω to √(3L/C) = 245 Ω. At 141.4 Ω such a part is 1.37° out at 100 MHz where the lumped model says 0.0027°. The third is a first-order rule; above about a gigahertz the helix is a line.

    part 3 · frequency
  4. A megohm part with one picofarad to its mounting, heavier at one end: 0.433 pF with that end driven and 0.233 pF turned round, 1.56° against 0.84° at 10 kHz. computed by solving, not by drawing: the angle of the impedance of a 1 MΩ resistor as 200 sections, with 1 pF in total from its film to its mounting tapered as c(x) ∝ 1 + a(1 − 2x), a = 0.6, read at the terminal with the far end grounded. Driving the end nearer the mounting (solid) it presents 0.433 pF and 1.56° at 10 kHz; turned round (dashed), 0.233 pF and 0.84°. The first-order weight is ∫c(x)(1 − x)²dx, which is C(1/3 + a/6) and C(1/3 − a/6). The part's total capacitance has not changed, nor has its resistance, and neither of the readings is that total.

    The resistor turned round

    A resistor's stray capacitance is usually drawn as one capacitor across its ends, and a stray to the part's mounting is not one number. Read at the terminal with the far end grounded it is weighted by the square of the distance from ground, so a uniform stray counts as a third of itself, and turned round a part with a tapered stray reads differently: 0.433 pF one way and 0.233 pF the other from one picofarad in all. In the current through the part the weight is x(1 − x), a sixth, and the current reaching the far end is 3 dB down at ωRC = 9.18 rather than at one. Two readings of one part separate the total from the taper, and a distributed stray's phase never reaches a capacitor's: it stops at 45 degrees.

    part 4 · frequency

All series