Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Concept

Electrical length — where it appears

A conductor's length as a fraction of the wavelength it carries, which decides whether it is a node in a circuit or a transmission line. The crossover is a length rather than a frequency for a given edge, which is why a rule about stubs is quoted in millimetres.

Named by 7 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

10.0 cm of track, solved as a lumped circuit and as a line. The two agree to 0.030% at 3.97 MHz, where the track is one degree long, and to 30.1% at 143 MHz, where it is a tenth of a wavelength. Above that the lumped model is not approximately right; it is describing a different object.

Kirchhoff's own frequency

The current law says the current entering a node equals the current leaving it at the same instant, which assumes the signal crosses the circuit in no time. It crosses at about two-thirds the speed of light, so the law has a frequency of its own — set by nothing but the physical size of the board.

limits · Lumped element The return under 10.0 cm of track, 200 µm above the plane. computed by solving, not by drawing, as an estimate from the geometry: a low-frequency path assumed to be three track-widths wide, 83.3 mΩ, and the parallel-plate inductance µ₀h/w, 125.7 nH, which is the limit for a track much wider than its height. The estimated resistance and reactance are equal at 106 kHz. Solved across the plane instead of assumed, the return does not change path at one frequency: it gathers beneath the track across a band about three decades wide, and this corner falls inside that band. Above the band the loop is the track's length times its height, 20.0 mm², and a milliamp round it at 100 MHz radiates -1.1 dBµV/m at three metres.

Where the current comes back

The return current under a track spreads out at low frequency and runs directly beneath it at high. Estimated from two paths chosen in advance, the change is a corner at 106 kilohertz for any track two hundred micrometres above a half-milliohm plane, with neither the length of the track nor its width in it. Solved, it is a band three decades wide rather than a corner, and the width enters it after all — but the length is still absent and the stack-up still sets the top, which is the part of the argument a designer needs.

lines · Return path From 50 Ω into 50 Ω: a T isolates to 643 MHz, a changeover to 6.34 MHz. computed by solving, not by drawing. The fraction of the drive that arrives with the path open, against frequency, from a 50 Ω source into 50 Ω, for the 0.5 Ω, 100 MΩ, 5 pF switch used three ways. A T reaches 1% at 643 MHz; a changeover reaches 1% at 6.34 MHz; one switch reaches 1% at 3.18 MHz.

The capacitance a third switch moves

A changeover's open channel leaks into the source of the channel that is closed, so its isolation into fifty ohms falls from 643 megahertz with a buffered source to 6.34 megahertz with a fifty-ohm one. Put a third switch to ground between two series switches and the leak lands on half an ohm of closed switch instead: 814, 643 and 2,240 megahertz from sources of nothing, fifty ohms and a kilohm, rising forty decibels a decade where a changeover's rises twenty. The price is the shunt switch's own capacitance, moved under the closed path, which makes the T one per cent wrong as a waveform at 6.59 megahertz beside the changeover's 6.61.

limits · Ideal switch 10.0 cm of track leaves 40 per cent on a 1 ns edge. The far end of 10.0 cm of 50 Ω track, driven from 10 Ω into 200 Ω, marched as the exact staircase of reflections it is and driven by a ramp rather than by a step. The staircase converges on the resistive divider the circuit was going to be all along, to a part in 10⁹, which is the number the lumped model returns immediately and with no staircase. What is left on the edge is an overshoot: 40.0 per cent at 0.1 ns, which is the first wave's own reflection coefficient and contains no rise time at all, falling to 0.399 per cent at 100 ns where the staircase happens inside the edge. It reaches ten per cent at an edge of 4.24 ns and one per cent at 40.0 — which is 28.6 times the 1.40 ns round trip. Nothing in the measurement is a repetition rate: the boundary is a transit time, a mismatch and a rise time, and the clock the signal repeats at does not enter.

The boundary that is a rise time

Kirchhoff's own frequency is 3.97 megahertz for ten centimetres of track, and a one-kilohertz clock is four thousand times below it — which is the reading that concludes wrongly. Marched as the exact staircase of reflections it is, the same track leaves forty per cent of overshoot on a one-nanosecond edge and 0.40 per cent on a hundred-nanosecond one, reaching one per cent at 40.0 nanoseconds. The boundary is a rise time, it is twenty-nine times the conductor's round trip, and the repetition rate is not in it anywhere.

limits · Lumped element A 1 ns edge from 10 Ω into 200 Ω on 50 Ω track stays inside one per cent of overshoot only up to 2.5 mm of track. computed by solving, not by drawing, the staircase of reflections marched against a ramp: the far end's overshoot against the track's length for a 1 ns edge, 50 Ω track on FR-4 driven from 10 Ω into 200 Ω. 2 mm: 0.79%; 5 mm: 1.98%; 10 mm: 3.98%; 20 mm: 8.07%; 50 mm: 22.93%; 100 mm: 40.00%; 200 mm: 40.00%; 500 mm: 40.00%. The longest track inside one per cent, bisected, is 2.51 mm — a round trip of 35 ps, the edge being 28.5 times it — and the rise-time boundary of that length is 0.994 ns, this edge given back.

How long a track may be

The lumped-element boundary read the way a layout is designed: given the edge, how long may the track be? For 50 Ω track driven from 10 Ω into 200 Ω, a 1 ns edge stays inside one per cent of overshoot for 2.51 mm, and every nanosecond of edge buys 2.52 mm more — proportional to within half a per cent from 0.1 ns to 30. The mismatch decides the rest. From 45 Ω the same edge may cross 23.5 mm; from 50 Ω, or anything above it into this load, no length overshoots at all; and into an open end, a CMOS input, 1.80 mm. The common rule — a track is short while its round trip is under the edge — allows 49 per cent of overshoot from a 5 Ω driver, and a tenth of its length still allows 3.3.

limits · Lumped element Near-end crosstalk from a 200 ps edge, 100 mm of coupled track against 10 mm. computed by solving, not by drawing, the pair solved mode by mode and returned to time from its harmonics. Over 100 mm the near end rises with the edge, holds a plateau of 12.51 mV per volt for twice the line's delay, 1.33 ns, and falls. Over 10 mm the round trip is shorter than the edge and the pulse never reaches the plateau: 8.34 mV. The plateau is Kb, a quarter of the sum of the two couplings, on the 0.5 V the driven line carries: 12.50 mV.

The near end that stops growing

Near-end crosstalk is a length only until the coupled run's round trip equals the edge's rise time; past that it is a constant. Solved mode by mode and returned to time, a 200 ps edge on 100 mm of coupled track gives a plateau of 12.51 mV per volt — Kb, a quarter of the sum of the two couplings, on the driven line's half-volt — held for the 1.33 ns round trip. The knee is at v·tr/2: 7 mm for a 100 ps edge, 75 mm for 1 ns. Past it a longer run adds width and not height, and the pulse's area keeps growing as Kb times the round trip.

lines · Crosstalk Where a chain of 4 stages stops obeying its model, against where one stage does. computed by solving, not by drawing. amplifier, 1%: one stage 14.2 kHz, 4 stages 7.06 kHz, a ratio of 0.498; Kirchhoff, 1°: one stage 3.97 MHz, 4 stages 993 kHz, a ratio of 0.250; small-signal, 1%: one stage 7.30 mV, 4 stages 7.26 µV, a ratio of 0.000995. The amplifier's edge moves as N to the −½ because its error grows as the square of frequency; the board's as N to the −1 because a phase grows in proportion; and the small-signal edge collapses, because the last stage sees the gain of all the others.

The edge of a chain

A system built from stages that are each inside their own edge is not inside its own: the stages share one error budget. Four ×10 stages from a 1 MHz amplifier are 1% from ideal at 7.06 kHz, not at the single stage's 14.2 kHz — the edge moves as N to the −0.502. A signal path through four ten-centimetre boards is a degree long at 993 kHz, a quarter of one board's edge, as N to the −1. The chain's exponent is minus the edge's own exponent in its tolerance, measured on the line y = −x. And the small-signal edge of a chain with gain belongs to its last stage: four junction stages of ten are 1% off at 7.26 µV, a thousandth of one stage's 7.30 mV.

limits · Model edges

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Lumped elementTransmission lineModel rangeDesign tradeoffLumped approximationParasiticsPropagation velocityReflectionsRise timeBisectionCharacteristic impedanceClosed-loop gain

All concepts