Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Concept

Lumped approximation — where it appears

The assumption that every element of a circuit acts at one instant, which holds while the circuit is small compared with a wavelength. The frequency at which it gives out is set by the size of the board and nothing else, which is the only boundary here that is a length.

Named by 9 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

20 inductor-capacitor sections, against the line they are meant to be. computed by solving, not by drawing by the trapezoidal rule over 2,600 steps. The LC ladder reaches two per cent of full scale at 0.86 delays, before the wave picture says anything can have arrived, and its plateaus are wrong by up to 0.079 V. Neither is a small correction to the wave answer; they are what a network of 20 poles does when asked to be a delay.

A ladder is not a line

A transmission line is usually introduced as the limit of a chain of inductors and capacitors as the number of sections goes to infinity. That is true, and it gives entirely the wrong impression of how close a finite chain gets. Forty sections still ring through every plateau by five per cent, and extrapolating the fitted convergence, reaching one per cent would need about nine hundred and sixty.

lines · Distributed vs lumped Two tracks, and a far end that cancels exactly when the field is all in one material. computed by solving, not by drawing, on 12 coupled sections of a 100 mm pair terminated in 50 Ω at all four ends. A mutual capacitance injects a current proportional to dV/dt and splits it towards both ends of the quiet track; a mutual inductance injects a voltage proportional to dI/dt and drives the two ends in opposite directions. So the near end goes as Cm/Ct + Lm/Lt and the far end as their difference, with the same constant in front of both — measured here as 1.048e-2 either way, over a slider that moves the ratio by five times. The consequence is that the far end is not a smaller effect but a cancellation: at a ratio of one it is 7.52e-19 of the drive, which is zero to the last bits of a double, while the near end is 1.048e-3. That is why a stripline has no far-end crosstalk and a microstrip has some — what shows up there measures the field that is in air, not the spacing. The model is lumped and stops where it says: a section is one degree long at 50.0 MHz.

The far end that cancels

Two mechanisms couple two parallel tracks: a mutual capacitance injecting a current and a mutual inductance injecting a voltage. They add at the near end of the quiet track and subtract at the far end, with the same constant in front of both — measured here as 1.048 times ten to the minus two either way, across a slider that moves their ratio by five times. So the far end is not a smaller effect: when the two couplings are equal it is 3.5 times ten to the minus nineteen of the drive, which is zero to the last bits of a double.

lines · Crosstalk The thermal network's step response, and the sum of its own stages — 0.95 per cent apart at worst. computed by solving, not by drawing. A step of power into a three-stage thermal ladder, and the junction's rise divided by it. The solid curve is exact: the impedance is a continued fraction in s, its denominator has 3 real negative roots, and the partial-fraction expansion of Z(s)/s is a sum of that many ordinary exponentials — no march, no step size. The dashed curve is the sum every account of a thermal path writes, each stage's own resistance times 1 − exp(−t/RC) with its own local time constant, and it is an approximation because the stages load each other. What that costs is 0.950 per cent, once, at 12.9 ms — between the fastest stage's 2.4 ms and the next one's 200 ms, which is the only place two stages are moving together. It is one-sided: the sum never reads low.

Two ladders the terminals cannot tell apart

A thermal path drawn as a ladder and the same path drawn as a sum of exponentials are called different models of one object, and the difference between them has never been priced because pricing it needs an exact answer. Solved in closed form, the sum is 0.950 per cent high at worst and never low; the marched netlist is right to a part in 21,169; and the largest disagreement in the picture was 2.919 per cent that has nothing to do with heat at all, which reading the curve one sample differently removes.

transients · Reverse recovery 20 sections imitating a 1 m line: its delay is 1% long at 318 MHz and its group delay at 185 MHz, and it passes nothing above 1.32 GHz. computed by solving, not by drawing, as a chain of 20 series inductors and shunt capacitors carrying the inductance and capacitance of a metre of 50 Ω line of delay 4.83 ns, terminated in 50 Ω at both ends, beside the Bloch phase of an endless chain, 2·arcsin of ω over the cutoff, a section. The chain's cutoff is the cutoff 2/√(LₛCₛ), 1.32 GHz. Its phase delay is too long by arcsin(x)/x − 1 with x = f over that cutoff, 1% at 318 MHz (x = 0.2417); its group delay by 1/√(1 − x²) − 1, 1% at 185 MHz (x = 0.1404). Well below cutoff the solved chain's delay follows the closed form; nearer it the fifty-ohm terminations, which are not the LC ladder's own impedance there, add a ripple. Ten sections per wavelength is 414 MHz for this chain.

The sections a wavelength needs

A ladder of inductors and capacitors is a line only below its own cutoff, 2/√(LC) of one section, and in the frequency domain how far below can be written down exactly: its delay is too long by arcsin(x)/x − 1 and its group delay by 1/√(1 − x²) − 1, where x is π over the number of sections per wavelength. One per cent of delay needs 13.0 sections per wavelength; one per cent of group delay, 22.4. The rule of ten per wavelength is 1.72 per cent slow in phase and 5.33 in group delay. Twenty sections imitating a metre of cable are a line to a per cent of group delay up to 185 megahertz and pass nothing at all above 1.32 gigahertz.

lines · Distributed vs lumped A 10 ps stub under a balanced via, and the pad it has to come out of. computed by solving, not by drawing, as a cascade. The reflection from a via of 0.5 pF of pad and 1 nH of barrel on its balancing line of 44.72 Ω, met by an edge of 59 ps, four ways: with no stub, whose largest excursion is 24.4 mV; with a 10 ps open stub below its bottom pad, 90.5 mV and an area of 5 ps; with the stub's 0.224 pF taken out of both pads, 56.1 mV; and taken out of the bottom pad alone, 24.6 mV. Both trims balance the area again. Only the second restores the doublet.

The pad the stub comes out of

A via used to a middle layer leaves barrel hanging below the connection: an open stub. Under a via balanced on its √(L/C) line, a 10 ps stub is 0.224 pF of extra capacitance, 5 ps of area, and a reflection of 90.5 mV where the balanced via gave 24.4. Taking that capacitance out of the pads balances the area again whichever pad it comes from. Only one restores the doublet: out of both pads the via still reflects 56.1 mV, out of the bottom pad the stub hangs from, 24.6. The trim works for every stub whose capacitance fits inside that pad, delays up to Z·C/2 = 11.2 ps, whose quarter wave is above 22.4 GHz. A longer stub has nothing left to come out of. At 40 ps it is a notch in the transmission at 6.25 GHz.

lines · Reflections From a 10 Ω driver with a 1 ns edge, a CMOS input of 1.5 pF allows only 0.86 mm of track — less than the bare open end's 1.80 — and one of 100 pF allows 10.9 mm. computed by solving, not by drawing, bisected on the march by characteristics: the longest 50 Ω track a 1 ns edge from a 10 Ω driver can cross into an open end with a capacitance across it and overshoot by less than one per cent, against the capacitance. With none it is 1.80 mm. 0.3 pF: 1.28 mm, 0.5 pF: 1.04 mm, 1 pF: 0.88 mm, 1.5 pF: 0.86 mm, 2 pF: 0.88 mm, 3 pF: 0.96 mm, 5 pF: 1.15 mm, 10 pF: 1.68 mm, 20 pF: 2.71 mm, 50 pF: 5.70 mm, 100 pF: 10.94 mm. The limit falls to its least, 0.86 mm, near 1.5 pF, and from there rises nearly in proportion to the capacitance (slope 0.87 between 20 and 100 pF), because the driver's resistance damps the ring the track's inductance makes with a heavy load. The slider is the driver's resistance.

The heavier input that allows a longer track

Put a capacitance across a CMOS input and the longest track a 1 ns edge from a 10 Ω driver may cross inside one per cent of overshoot does not shrink steadily. It falls from the bare open end's 1.80 mm to 0.86 mm at 1.5 pF, and then it rises — 2.71 mm at 20 pF, 10.9 at 100 — nearly in proportion to the capacitance. A heavy load turns the track into the inductor of a series RLC whose damping, (Rₛ/2)·√(C/L), the driver's resistance supplies, and at every heavy load the one-per-cent length sits at the same damping, about 0.8. So the limit scales as Rₛ²·C: a slower edge buys a 20 pF input only the 0.4 power of its length, and a stronger driver — 2 Ω instead of 10 — cuts the track it may drive from 2.71 mm to 0.20. Into a heavy input, a weak driver is the clean one.

limits · Lumped element Near-end crosstalk from a 200 ps edge, 100 mm of coupled track against 10 mm. computed by solving, not by drawing, the pair solved mode by mode and returned to time from its harmonics. Over 100 mm the near end rises with the edge, holds a plateau of 12.51 mV per volt for twice the line's delay, 1.33 ns, and falls. Over 10 mm the round trip is shorter than the edge and the pulse never reaches the plateau: 8.34 mV. The plateau is Kb, a quarter of the sum of the two couplings, on the 0.5 V the driven line carries: 12.50 mV.

The near end that stops growing

Near-end crosstalk is a length only until the coupled run's round trip equals the edge's rise time; past that it is a constant. Solved mode by mode and returned to time, a 200 ps edge on 100 mm of coupled track gives a plateau of 12.51 mV per volt — Kb, a quarter of the sum of the two couplings, on the driven line's half-volt — held for the 1.33 ns round trip. The knee is at v·tr/2: 7 mm for a 100 ps edge, 75 mm for 1 ns. Past it a longer run adds width and not height, and the pulse's area keeps growing as Kb times the round trip.

lines · Crosstalk Where a chain of 4 stages stops obeying its model, against where one stage does. computed by solving, not by drawing. amplifier, 1%: one stage 14.2 kHz, 4 stages 7.06 kHz, a ratio of 0.498; Kirchhoff, 1°: one stage 3.97 MHz, 4 stages 993 kHz, a ratio of 0.250; small-signal, 1%: one stage 7.30 mV, 4 stages 7.26 µV, a ratio of 0.000995. The amplifier's edge moves as N to the −½ because its error grows as the square of frequency; the board's as N to the −1 because a phase grows in proportion; and the small-signal edge collapses, because the last stage sees the gain of all the others.

The edge of a chain

A system built from stages that are each inside their own edge is not inside its own: the stages share one error budget. Four ×10 stages from a 1 MHz amplifier are 1% from ideal at 7.06 kHz, not at the single stage's 14.2 kHz — the edge moves as N to the −0.502. A signal path through four ten-centimetre boards is a degree long at 993 kHz, a quarter of one board's edge, as N to the −1. The chain's exponent is minus the edge's own exponent in its tolerance, measured on the line y = −x. And the small-signal edge of a chain with gain belongs to its last stage: four junction stages of ten are 1% off at 7.26 µV, a thousandth of one stage's 7.30 mV.

limits · Model edges A line ten rises long stood in for by 20 LC sections, matched at both ends: the edge overshoots 17.5% and takes 1.66 rises to climb, where the line delivers it unchanged. computed by solving, not by drawing: an edge of 10–90% rise tr at the far end of a chain of 20 LC sections with a total delay of 10 tr, matched at both ends, marched (solid), against the same edge delayed by exactly 10 tr, which is what a line delivers (dashed). Overshoot 17.5%, rise 1.66 tr. With no reflections at either end, everything here is the chain's own dispersion: a section has a group delay that rises with frequency, so the fast end of the edge arrives late and rings behind it.

The sections an edge needs

A chain of LC sections rings on an ideal step however many sections it has, because a step has energy all the way to the chain's cut-off. An edge has a top frequency, and for a matched chain carrying one the section count has a clean answer: for one per cent of overshoot, 6 sections on a line one rise long, 183 on ten rises and 5,760 on a hundred, 5.8 times the length in rises to the three-halves power, within a few per cent from end to end. So sections per rise is not a constant. A section's phase error goes as the cube of frequency and the inverse square of the count, and it accumulates along the line. A 1 ns edge on a metre of cable asks for 62 sections, a 100 ps edge for 2,048, and the delay is right long before the edge is.

lines · Distributed vs lumped

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Transmission lineArtificial delay lineConvergence orderModel rangePower law fitRise timeCharacteristic impedanceCrosstalkElectrical lengthGroup delayMutual capacitanceMutual inductance

All concepts