Circuit Response
every model has an edge, and the figure carries it
Concept

Lumped-element — where it appears

A component treated as acting at a single point, with no length and no propagation delay anywhere inside it. A ladder of them approaches a real line as the section count rises, and how slowly it does so is measured here rather than assumed.

Named by 10 essays across 3 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Where four of this site's models stop being true. In order: the ideal operational amplifier at 1.42 kHz, a 10 V output at full amplitude at 7.96 kHz, Kirchhoff's laws on 10.0 cm at 3.97 MHz, the ideal 100 nF capacitor at 4.69 MHz. The fifth boundary is an amplitude rather than a frequency and cannot share this axis: a small-signal model is 1% wrong above 7.3 mV, at every frequency there is.

Every model has an edge

Four assumptions this collection runs on, with the frequency at which each stops being true, on one axis. The ordering is not the one most readers would guess — an ordinary amplifier circuit runs out of model at 1.42 kHz, three thousand times sooner than a ten-centimetre circuit board does.

limits · Model edges 10.0 cm of track, solved as a lumped circuit and as a line. The two agree to 0.030% at 3.97 MHz, where the track is one degree long, and to 30.1% at 143 MHz, where it is a tenth of a wavelength. Above that the lumped model is not approximately right; it is describing a different object.

Kirchhoff's own frequency

The current law says the current entering a node equals the current leaving it at the same instant, which assumes the signal crosses the circuit in no time. It crosses at about two-thirds the speed of light, so the law has a frequency of its own — set by nothing but the physical size of the board.

limits · Lumped-element Where four of this site's models stop being true. In order: the ideal operational amplifier at 1.42 kHz, a 10 V output at full amplitude at 7.96 kHz, Kirchhoff's laws on 10.0 cm at 3.97 MHz, the ideal 100 nF capacitor at 4.69 MHz. The fifth boundary is an amplitude rather than a frequency and cannot share this axis: a small-signal model is 1% wrong above 7.3 mV, at every frequency there is.

The edges that are lengths

Almost every boundary in this collection is a frequency or an amplitude, and both of those are things a circuit designer chooses. A handful are lengths — the 0.60 millimetres a gap's field reaches into a window, the 200 microns between a track and its plane, the 10 centimetres at which Kirchhoff's laws are a degree out — and they behave differently in one way that matters: nobody chooses them at the schematic, they are set by whoever builds the thing, and they appear in no netlist at all.

limits · Model edges A 10 kΩ resistor, and the 19.3 MHz it is one below. computed by solving, not by drawing. The dashed line is R, which is what the symbol means. The solid line is the same part with 8.0 nH of lead inductance in series and 0.40 pF across the body, solved as a three-element network and checked against the closed form for the same three elements to 3.3e-16. It is ten per cent below its own value by 19.3 MHz, and which of the two parasitics does that depends on the resistance: the shunt capacitance wins above 91.02 Ω and the lead inductance below it. The slider is the resistance, and the departure frequency it moves is not monotonic — it rises a decade per decade of resistance, peaks near 91.02 Ω at 2.00 GHz, and falls a decade per decade after that.

The resistor that is only a resistor

A capacitor becomes an inductor above a frequency its leads decide, and an inductor becomes a capacitor. The third member of that family is the one nobody draws, and it is the only one whose edge is not monotonic in its own value: a ten-megohm resistor stops being one at 19 kilohertz, a ten-ohm resistor at 92 megahertz, and between them sits a resistance whose impedance is flat to fourth order — 91.02 ohms here, which is the square root of L over C divided by the root of one plus root two.

frequency · Real resistor Five boundaries, one tolerance, and three exponents. computed by solving, not by drawing. Each of five model boundaries re-solved at forty-one tolerances from 0.1% to 30%, divided by its own value at 0.1% so that an amplitude in millivolts and four frequencies can share one axis — an exponent has no units. Fitted over the two decades to 10%: Kirchhoff's laws 1.000, the ideal amplifier 0.513, the small-signal model 0.497, the ideal capacitor 0.500, and the full-power bandwidth 0.000. A boundary set by a first-order departure moves in proportion to the tolerance, one set by a second-order departure moves as its square root, and a refusal does not move at all — so relaxing the tolerance from 0.1% to 10% buys a factor of 100 on the board and 10.0 on the capacitor.

A boundary is a model and a tolerance

Every edge in this collection is computed from a fraction of error nobody states, and the four on its opening axis use three different ones. Swept over two decades, each boundary moves as a power of that fraction — Kirchhoff's laws exactly as the first power, the amplifier and the capacitor and the small-signal model as its square root to within three per cent, and a full-power bandwidth not at all. The exponent identifies the mechanism, and it re-orders the axis twice: the board fails before the capacitor below 0.424 per cent, and the output before the amplifier above 21.7.

limits · Model edges Flat in angle at √(L/C), 141.42 Ω, and flat in size at 91.018 Ω. computed by solving, not by drawing, at 127 resistances on the closed form the network was checked against. The upper curve is the frequency at which the part's size is 1% away from R, the lower one the frequency at which its angle reaches 1°. Both are V-shaped and their points are in different places: the angle's first-order term vanishes at √(L/C) = 141.42 Ω, bisected on the measured slope to ten figures, and the size's second-order term at 91.018 Ω. The widest 1° band is 1.13 GHz, at 150.69 Ω; the widest 1% band is 1.66 GHz, at 95.806 Ω. At 91.018 Ω, flattest in size, the angle reaches 1° by 53.9 MHz. The flat line is 139 MHz, where a 6 mm body is one degree long: it binds the angle's edge from 118.72 Ω to 168.88 Ω and the size's from 43.947 Ω to 359.53 Ω.

The resistor that is right in size and wrong in angle

A resistor's impedance departs from its value in size as the square of frequency and in angle as the first power, so the angle always leaves first: at ten milliohms and at a megohm alike, where the angle has reached a degree the size is still only 152 parts per million out. One time constant, L/R − RC, sets that degree — 4.00 nanoseconds and 695 kilohertz at ten kilohms, 800 nanoseconds and 3.47 kilohertz for a ten-milliohm shunt. The resistance flattest in angle is exactly √(L/C), 141.42 ohms, the value the size question rejected; at the 91.02 ohms flattest in size the angle reaches a degree by 53.9 megahertz, and no resistance is flat in both.

frequency · Real resistor From 50 Ω into 50 Ω: a T isolates to 643 MHz, a changeover to 6.34 MHz. computed by solving, not by drawing. The fraction of the drive that arrives with the path open, against frequency, from a 50 Ω source into 50 Ω, for the 0.5 Ω, 100 MΩ, 5 pF switch used three ways. A T reaches 1% at 643 MHz; a changeover reaches 1% at 6.34 MHz; one switch reaches 1% at 3.18 MHz.

The capacitance a third switch moves

A changeover's open channel leaks into the source of the channel that is closed, so its isolation into fifty ohms falls from 643 megahertz with a buffered source to 6.34 megahertz with a fifty-ohm one. Put a third switch to ground between two series switches and the leak lands on half an ohm of closed switch instead: 814, 643 and 2,240 megahertz from sources of nothing, fifty ohms and a kilohm, rising forty decibels a decade where a changeover's rises twenty. The price is the shunt switch's own capacitance, moved under the closed path, which makes the T one per cent wrong as a waveform at 6.59 megahertz beside the changeover's 6.61.

limits · Ideal switch 1 pF across a 50 Ω line: a dip of 0.320 V and an area of 25 ps. computed by solving, not by drawing as a cascade of two-ports, with a raised-cosine edge of 59 ps sent into it. The incident edge is the faint curve; what comes back is the shaded dip and what goes on is the third. The dip reaches -0.3202 V and its area is 25 ps, which is Z₀C/2 to a part in ten thousand. Driven by an edge fifty times faster the same cascade returns the single exponential the closed form gives, to 9.3e-6 of a volt. The transmitted edge leaves at 81.1 ps, against 59 ps arriving.

The dip whose area is fixed

A picofarad across a 50 Ω line makes a dip in what comes back. Its depth is 0.833 volts to a six-picosecond edge and 0.0196 volts to a nanosecond one, forty-two times less; its area is 25 picoseconds to both, to six parts in a hundred thousand, because the area is Z₀C/2 and contains nothing about the edge. Two half-picofarad discontinuities too close to tell apart read as exactly one picofarad, and so do two far enough apart to be separate — the area is additive where the depth is not. And what a reflectometer calls the capacitance of an impedance step is the step's real excess capacitance times 1 + Z/Z₀.

lines · Reflections A via's area changes sign at 44.7 Ω, and two impedances give its 0.5 pF and 1 nH back. computed by solving, not by drawing, as a cascade of two-ports: a via of 0.25 pF, 1 nH and 0.25 pF, met by an edge of 59 ps from reference lines of 20 to 150 Ω. The area under the reflection is −Z₀C/2 + L/2Z₀ at every impedance: a bump below 44.7 Ω, where the inductance's term is the larger, nothing at it, and a dip above. From 50 Ω the area is 2.5 ps of dip, which a single-capacitance reading calls 0.100 pF. From 50 and 75 Ω together the two areas give 0.5000 pF and 1.0000 nH. An error of 50 fs on each area moves them by up to 0.8% and 1.5%.

The via two lines can weigh

The area under a reflection is a property of the discontinuity rather than of the edge, and for a via it is one number made of two: −Z₀C/2 from its pads and +L/2Z₀ from its barrel, with opposite signs. A via of half a picofarad and a nanohenry, seen from fifty ohms, leaves 2.5 picoseconds of dip — which a reading that assumes a capacitor calls 0.100 pF, a fifth of what is there. From fifty and seventy-five ohms together the two areas give 0.5000 pF and 1.0000 nH back, and fifty femtoseconds of error on each costs 0.8 per cent of the capacitance and 1.5 of the inductance. A second line at fifty-five ohms costs five times as much.

lines · Reflections At 44.7 Ω the via's area is zero; its reflection is a doublet falling as the 1.99 power of the edge, not the first. computed by solving, not by drawing, as a cascade. A via of 0.25 pF, 1 nH and 0.25 pF on a line of √(L/C) = 44.72 Ω, met by an edge of 59 ps, against the same capacitance alone on the same line. The via's reflection is a doublet — a dip and a bump of equal area — whose largest excursion is 24.4 mV against 166 mV for the capacitance alone. Over edges from 5.9 ps to 295 ps the capacitance's reflection falls as the −0.97 power of the edge and the via's as the −1.99 power: 24.4 mV at 59 ps, 994 µV at 295 ps. The via delays the edge going past it by 22.4 ps, against √(LC) = 22.4 ps.

The via that is a piece of line

A via of half a picofarad of pad and a nanohenry of barrel puts no area under its reflection from a line of √(L/C) = 44.72 ohms, from any edge. It has not vanished. It delays the edge going past it by 22.4 picoseconds, which is √(LC) exactly, and it still reflects: a doublet whose largest excursion falls as the −1.99 power of the edge where a lone capacitance's falls as the −0.97 — 24.4 millivolts for a 59-picosecond edge against 166 for the pads alone, and 994 microvolts for a 295-picosecond one against 35. The balanced via is a short piece of line, and the reflection it leaves is the reflection of its length rather than of its size.

lines · Reflections

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Model rangeParasiticsCharacteristic impedanceTransmission lineDesign tradeoffMeasurement conditionReflection coefficientRise timeSelf-resonanceElectrical lengthGain–bandwidth productLead inductance

All concepts